The true crime genre has seen a surge in popularity throughout the 2020s, but with this rise comes significant controversy. Critics argue that many series glorify killers and exploit victims, sparking heated debates about the ethical implications of such portrayals.
Amidst this landscape, Universal Content Productions (UCP) has introduced a fresh perspective with its limited series Devil in Disguise: John Wayne Gacy. Starring Michael Chernus as the infamous Chicago-based killer, the series distinguishes itself by avoiding graphic depictions of Gacy’s crimes. Instead, it shines a light on the systemic failures that allowed these tragedies to occur, offering a gripping narrative that respects the victims’ stories.
The Art of Balancing Respect and Engagement
A recent panel discussion at USG Universitymoderated by IndieWiredelved into the creative process behind Devil in Disguise: John Wayne Gacy. The panel featured Patrick Macmanusthe series’ creator and showrunner, along with star Michael Chernusproduction designer Rory Cheyneand composers Leopold Ross and Nick Chuba.
Macmanus emphasized the collective commitment to the series’ mission: “What I am very proud of, of everyone who has been a part of this show, is that we all understood what the mission was. Which was not just to do it differently, but to pay respect to the victims and their histories. We didn’t show a single murder on screen, we didn’t any acts of violence on screen, and yet I think we still had that true crime velocity that people come to expect while also doing something different.”
A Collaborative Effort to Honor Victims
The victim-centric approach of Devil in Disguise: John Wayne Gacy permeated every aspect of the production. From the set design to the musical score, each department worked diligently to ensure the series remained respectful and engaging. Production designer Rory Cheyne highlighted the importance of creating an atmosphere that reflected the gravity of the subject matter without resorting to sensationalism.
Composers Leopold Ross and Nick Chuba discussed the challenges of crafting a score that evoked the necessary emotions without crossing into exploitation. Their collaboration resulted in a hauntingly beautiful soundtrack that complements the series’ tone and enhances the viewing experience.
The Impact of ‘Devil in Disguise: John Wayne Gacy’
Since its release, Devil in Disguise: John Wayne Gacy has garnered praise for its innovative approach to true crime storytelling. By focusing on the victims and the broader societal issues that contributed to the tragedies, the series offers a nuanced exploration of a dark chapter in history.
The series is now streaming exclusively on Peacockproviding viewers with a thought-provoking alternative to traditional true crime narratives. As part of Universal Studio Group‘s commitment to diverse and impactful storytelling, Devil in Disguise: John Wayne Gacy stands as a testament to the power of responsible and respectful storytelling.
USG Universitypresented in partnership with the Motion Picture & Television Fundcontinues to celebrate the artistry and craftsmanship behind the 2026–2026 television season, showcasing the outstanding work of creators and artists across NBCUniversal‘s portfolio.
